Suicidal Lies Normally I’m not
Sunday, March 31st, 2002Normally I’m not a fan of Tom Friedman. But this is actually a pretty good column.
As horrendous and bloody as a war in the Middle East would be, and as much as I would NOT like to see the situation come to that, it is time to stop playing footsie with Yasser Arafat. Let’s recap some history:
1948: The State of Israel is established by the UN, which includes an internationally-controlled Jerusalem. It is established in the area commonly known as Palestine, which was under the control of the British Empire at the time, which donated the land for the purpose of founding a Jewish state. Within hours of Israel formally becoming a sovereign state, more or less the entire Arab world launches a war on it.
1949: Israel, which barely had time to pull itself together, succeeds in fighting them off.
1964: The Arab League charters the Palestinian Liberation Organization for the purposes of “the destruction of Israel” and the “establishment of a sovereign Palestinian state.”
1967: The USSR tells Syria that Israel is amassing troops on its border (which was a total falsehood), and Syria grabs Egypt and they start amassing troops on Israel’s borders. They eventually get the Saudis, Sidan, Algeia, Jordan, and Iraq to join in. Facing a three-front war against Arabs who were literally announcing to the world, “We’re ready to attack Israel, y’all!” Israel launches a pre-emptive strike and kicks their asses back to where they came from within 6 days, taking some territory in the process as an insulator. Arabs in general, and Palestinians in particular, start bitching about how Israel is “occupying their territory.” Never mind the fact that they tried to occupy Israel’s territory by preparing to invade in the first place. Also, the territory Israel annexed had both strategic and spiritual significance. It included the Sinai Desert and the Golan Heights.
It was at this point that Israel started offering “Land for Peace.” In other words, “we’ll give you back your land if you just stop f’n PICKING ON US.”
Oh, and by the time the war started, Israel was officially a nuclear power.
1973: Apparently not learning their lesson, the Yom Kippur war is launched against Israel. Israel beats them back within three weeks.
1974: The Arab League names the PLO “the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people,” and rejects UN Resolutions 242 and 338, which establish Israel’s right to exist within UN-established borders and calls on all parties to abandon belligerency.
1978-79: The Camp David Accords: Egypt and Israel make peace. Israel hands back the Sinai peninsula and Egypt recognizes Israel’s right to exist.
As a result of this peace, the Arab League removes its HQ from Cairo, several Arab nations sign a resolution encouraging “progressive and nationalistic” forces in Egypt to overthrow Anwar al-Sadat, the Egyptian leader, and an Arab joint political and military command is formed to coordinate moves against Israel and Egypt. Sadat is assassinated not long thereafter. But to this day, Egypt and Israel are still at peace- Egypt did not attend this most recent Arab summit.
1993: The Oslo peace treaty between Israel and the PLO is signed.
1994: Israel and Jordan sign a peace treaty, promising “mutual understanding and cooperation in security-related matters,” full diplomatic relations, free trade, and recognition of Israel’s right to exist. Jordan, incidentally, also did not attend this most recent Arab summit.
[/history lesson]
It’s not that I’m suggesting that Israel has been totally innocent in all of this. But let’s look at who the aggressor has consistently been. Let’s look at how Arafat has paid lip service to peace with Israel, but has consistently tolerated terrorism against Israel. Hell, the PLO started out as (still is) an umbrella group for a motley crew of terrorist organizations.
Let’s remember how Israel, surrounded on all sides by people who hate it and would like to see it destroyed, hasn’t had a moment’s real peace since its founding.
Let’s note that Israel has historically demonstrated its willingness to hand back lands that it has taken for nothing more than the promise that it will be left alone.
Let’s note that Israel has had the opportunity on more than one occasion to kill Arafat and wipe the Palestinians from the face of the planet, but has stayed its hand. Hell, Israel let the US talk it into NOT retaliating when Saddam Hussein was launching Scuds into Tel Aviv.
Let’s note that while Ariel Sharon may have no use for a Palestinian state, he did not come to power in a vacuum. Israel is a democracy, and his power comes from the Israelis who elected him because they are tired of offering the olive branch only to be beaten with it.
Finally, let’s note that while Ariel Sharon may really have no use for that Palestinian state, he SURELY has a use for Israel’s alliance with the United States, which has ALWAYS supported a Palestinian state. Sharon is a hawk, but he’s no dummy.
While turning Arafat into a martyr is not going to solve the problems, Israel has demonstrated that it is strong enough on its own, and definitely strong enough with US support, to hold off the attack that would come from such an action until someone more reasonable could come to the table on behalf of the Palestinians. Like Jordan, for example - the majority of Jordanian citizens are ethnically Palestinian. In fact, there are more Palestinians in Jordan than there are in the West Bank. If there is any legitimate voice of the Palestinian people, it is the King of Jordan.
And wouldn’t it be easier to sit at the table with Jordan than with Yasser-fucking-Arafat?
Yes, it would be bloody and terrible war. Yes, that is a bad thing. No, I don’t think it can be avoided. Yes, it may be necessary. We’re talking about people, after all, whose goal in life is to die in the fight against Israel. Israel can fight back, or it can allow more grandparents to be blown to bits on their way to Seder.